Did Mattia Binotto’s Mercedes-style ‘no blame’ philosophy cost him his job?

Ex-F1 driver Karun Chandhok believes Mattia Binotto gave his Ferrari team too much protection during the 2022 season.
(L to R): Mattia Binotto (ITA) Ferrari Team
(L to R): Mattia Binotto (ITA) Ferrari Team

Binotto will leave his role as Ferrari team boss at the end of ❀the month, bringing an end to his four-year stint at the helm of the tea🔜m.

Ferrari managed just four wins in 2022, co✅mpared👍 to Red Bull’s 17.

Remote video URL

The Italian giant did have the fastest car over one lap for mu♒ch of the season but a combination of poor strategy and ope🌸rations errors cost them.

Sky Sports F1 commentator David Croft believes Binotto’s attempts to implement a no blame culture at Ferra🍬ri - like Toto Wolff has at Mercedes - may have cost him his job.

“Did Mattia Binotto pay the price for a season of over expectation?” Croft said. “No is the answer to that. As y🌌ou say, they’ve engineered the fastest car. Did he pay the price for trying to protect the staff at Maranello for the intense scrutiny and any public blame?

“Yes I think he dꦬid. Toto Wolff crea🔴tes a culture of no blame at Mercedes. Mattia tries to do the same at Ferrari. One is feted for that but the other has to resign for that.”

Chandhok - who is a pundit for Sky - was quick to poi🌺nt out the key difference between Binotto and Wolff’s management style.

“There’s a difference because there’s one thing about creating a no blame culture, however, if someone is not performing - in their  case the strategy wasn’t - you have to make changes,” he added. “Mattia perhaps leaned towards protecting the pe⛦ople and not sacking people mid-season, and maybe hesitated from making the changes required.”

Mattia Binotto (ITA) Ferrari Team Principal. Formula 1 World Championship, Rd 19, United States Grand Prix, Austin, Texas,
Mattia Binotto (ITA) Ferrari Team Principal. Formula 1 World Championship, Rd 19, United…

The former HRT and Lotus F1 driver doesn’t beli꧅eve swapping Binotto for Frederic Vasseur will cure Ferrari’s plethora of problems.

“I don’t necessarily thi🐓nk that’s the answer,” Chandhok explained. “It feels a bit football manager-esque. There were issues on the operational side. If you look at it from a technical standpoint, in terms of R&a🤡mp;D and design, they produced a very fast car. 

“They had the🧸 fastest car over one lap this yea🔯r but operationally, reliability-wise they had issues. I don’t think just changing the person at the top is the answer.”

Read More